As the Rangers' management team gets ready to convene for their organizational meetings this week, they have three major holes on the team they have to figure out how to fill -- the first line, their top offensive and physical defensemen, and their depth positions. And it won't be easy, as they will have about $20 million of cap space to work with, with at least three and maybe four expensive positions to fill on their top unit, and some potentially costly returning veterans as depth players. Here is a breakdown of what they will be looking at:
First Line Wingers
Plan A: Bring the Boys Back Home -- Re-signing Jaromir Jagr and Sean Avery has got to be at the top of the Rangers' list. At 36 and having proven in March and April what he is still capable of doing, signing Jagr to a bonus-laden contract that can be partially deferred into the 2009-10 cap calculation seems almost imperative in order to properly fill other holes, especially on defense. Avery is not traditional first line material, but his chemistry with Jagr when they skated together got both players restarted offensively after inconsistent seasons up to that point. But no matter where he skates, there is no denying his impact on the team -- the Rangers are 60-28-15 with him in the line-up, 35-38-8 over the past two full seasons without him. If Jagr is re-signed but Avery is not, Martin Straka remains an inexpensive possibility for one more season, though he looked like he was close to be through last season.
Plan B: Hired Guns -- A look at the list of potential free agents demonstrates just how vital it is for the Rangers to re-sign Jagr and Avery. Marian Hossa is the top name, maybe even the only name, but he will want more than the $7 million he made last season -- a lot more, especially after a so-far successful post-season, the one knock against him. Though the Rangers have already been linked to him, there is just no way they will be able to afford him and still fill their other holes. Plus there is the fact that he is not going to shake the label of being soft, which is the case with most of the other viable high-scoring UFA candidates -- Markus Naslund, Pavol Demitra, Miro Satan, and Cory Stillman are all aging and far removed from their best days, while Kristian Huselius and Michael Ryder, also soft, are not going to make anyone forget Jagr. The only possible replacement for Avery is Pittsburgh's Ryan Malone, but why replace an overachieving sparkplug with a career underachiever?
Plan C: Home Cooking -- There was a lack of candidates to begin with, and no one is ready -- the only draftee projected to be a first-liner is Alexei Cherepanov, and he has already decided to stay in Russia another season because he's not ready for the NHL.
First Pair Defenseman
Plan A: Bring the Boys Back Home -- No, not Marek Malik. But Michal Rozsival remains a viable candidate to reprise his role as number on Ranger defenseman despite fans turning on him in the playoffs. He has the skill set to play both ends of the ice -- not to the level of perfection Ranger fans demand, but certainly to the requirements of team management and the standards the NHL allows in this era. He will also not require the kind of money needed to sign the true top-pair minute-munching two-way all-star defenseman the Rangers really need -- and some don't believe Wade Redden is really that player anyway.
Plan B: Hired Guns -- Plenty of candidates here, unlike the situation on the wing, but there is no perfect candidate. Redden is the ideal two-way defender the Rangers most need, but will he be two to three million dollars better than Rozsival? Probably not for a team that will be cap-strapped and may need a power play quarterback more than his type of player. Brian Campbell is the best candidate for the power play, but once Ranger fans see his defensive play on a regular basis, they will not be able to distinguish him from Tom Poti, except by his humongous cap hit. John-Michael Liles and Ron Hainsey will be lower-cost options in this mold. On the physical side, Brooks Orpik is the obvious choice, but don't overlook Dmitri Kalinin (though he is injury prone) and Mike Commodore.
Plan C: Home Cooking -- One reason not to commit to someone like Campbell or Redden for a long term is the potential of Bobby Sanguinetti and Marc Staal as the first pair of the future. Staal is already here and has lots of time and room to grow. But it would be unwise to hope to capture lightning in a bottle twice in a row and have Sanguinetti step right into a top-pair role as a rookie -- he may ultimately prove to be great, but he's not an out-of-the box can't-miss candidate like a Staal. He and the Rangers can only benefit from patience -- a year of seasoning in the AHL and at least a year of low-expectation development in the NHL before anointing him the next Brian Leetch.
Depth Positions
The Rangers' current $35 million cap commitment that we're operating under includes what we might expect Nigel Dawes and Fred Sjostrom to get as restricted free agents and it includes a modest allotment for a back-up goalie, whether it be Steve Valiquette, Miika Wiikman, or David Leneveu. It also includes Thomas Pock as the sixth or seventh defenseman, plus the entire fourth line as constituted last season, all three already signed for next year. But there are still three depth spots to fill to complete the roster, and that will take up some cap space too.
Plan A: Bring the Boys Back Home -- There is no reason to expect or even want Blair Betts and Colton Orr to be replaced, both having proved their value last season (when was the last time you saw someone run a Ranger with Orr in the line-up?). Ryan Hollweg should be up for challenge, but even if he loses his starting job, he will likely remain as a depth player for his hitting and locker room popularity, an intangible factor not to be overlooked. On defense, Pock will get his last chance to make the Rangers, but has to be considered a longshot. You could do worse than bring back Paul Mara at the deep discount he is now worth. But the big issue in this area is the status of Brendan Shanahan -- he said he'd be willing to return as a depth player, but will he be too expensive in that role, or is his leadership worth it?
Plan B: Hired Guns -- Branislav Mezei might be a good cheap option with potential upside as a depth defenseman if Mara is not signed. Or maybe even if Mara is re-signed and the Rangers do the right thing and cut Christian Backman, freeing up some salary for more important players -- a soft, porous defenseman like Backman can be obtained for a lot less than he makes, or can better yet be removed from your game plan altogether. There is no need to sign any free agent forwards for depth.
Plan C: Home Cooking -- There are two options up front: One is to open up a third line role for a player with offensive upside like Lauri Korpikoski and let him compete for that job in training camp, leaving Sjostrom on the fourth line with Betts and Orr. The more likely option is to let a number of young players compete for one or two openings on the fourth line -- Korpikoski and Greg Moore as potential upside players cutting their teeth in the NHL, or Josh Gratton and Dane Byers as permanent replacements for Hollweg. On defense, Corey Potter is the dark horse Girardi-du-jour candidate as depth defenseman. Paging Ivan Baranka -- last chance to show something in training camp.
Our opinion, taking the salary cap into consideration: Re-sign Jagr, Avery, Rozsival, and maybe Mara, waive Backman, and sign a mid-level defenseman if salaries don't escalate too high -- Liles, Hainsey, or Marc Streit for the power play or Orpik as a hitter -- or a cheaper physical alternative (Kalinin or Mezei). Let Shanahan and Straka go. Malik obviously already gone. Give Korpikoski, Moore, Gratton, Byers, Potter, and Baranka first shot at the depth positions. Hard to imagine any good fall-back positions if these things don't happen -- gotta just say nyet to big-ticket UFAs Hossa, Redden, and Campbell, and an even bigger nyet to the aging wingers or younger candidates who are either soft or underachievers.
Catching up on links from over the weekend: Larry Brooks takes on the Avery situation in the Post, as does Stan Fischler at MSG.com -- Stan also looks at Rozsival at MSG.com. Also in the Post (but in a blog), Jay Greenberg looks at Jagr alternatives. The Boston Herald mentions the Rangers among candidates for Hossa. Prospect Park finishes up its review of the Rangers and previews the upcoming draft. NYR.com has stories on Rangers in the World Championships here and here. And this just in -- updates from Rangers Report and Blue Notes with no news, and Cablevision just bought Newsday, a newspaper that covers the Rangers and Islanders. Brandon Dubinsky had a hat trick in Team USA's 9-1 win over Norway.
Thanks to all the readers for their kind words about this web site and about Blueshirt Bulletin's print publication as we face a summer of potential change. Thanks also for those who sent in for subscriptions -- not the 500-1000 that we really need, but your support is appreciated and your first issue is on its way to you.